5.0 1 2 3 4 5 15 Reviews

From Shirley, NY Homeowners

Garage Door Repair in Shirley, NY

Precision Garage Door

Same-day garage door repair in Shirley, NY, with 24/7 live phone support, openers, new garage door installation & emergency service. We Fix Garage Doors Right ®.

Garage Door Repair in Shirley, NY FREE Service Call With Any Repair Valued at $69

Serving Shirley, NY

Proudly serving the Shirley, NY community with same day service.

Service truck

Local Garage Door Repair in Shirley, NY

Precision Garage Door of Long Island provides same-day garage door repair in Shirley, NY, with 24/7 live phone support. We repair garage doors and openers of nearly all makes and models and provide free estimates on new garage doors and openers.

Shirley, NY homeowners call us for broken springs, noisy or malfunctioning doors, garage door opener problems, and doors that won't open or close properly. Our technicians provide clear explanations and upfront pricing before work begins.

The reviews below are from customers who have used Precision Garage Door for service in and around Shirley and reflect their experiences with our technicians, repairs, and customer service.

Same Day Service

We fix it fast, often the same day

Upfront Pricing

Honest, flat-rate pricing with no surprises

Local & Trusted

Proudly serving local communities

Map of Shirley, NY

Serving Shirley, NY

and surrounding communities

View all Service Areas

What Customers are Saying

Summary based on the 15 most recent customer reviews

Precision Garage Door of Long Island in Shirley is praised for professional, knowledgeable technicians who explain the work clearly, arrive promptly, and complete repairs and installations efficiently. Customers also frequently highlight courteous service, strong communication, and dependable results, with several reviewers saying the work was done right the first time and left them happy to recommend the company.

What Customers in Your Area Mention Most

Professionalism (8) Reviewers repeatedly describe technicians as professional, polite, courteous, respectful, and personable, creating a strong impression of reliable in-home service. Expertise (8) Customers consistently say the technicians were knowledgeable, informed, and able to understand the problem and explain the repair clearly. Communication (7) Reviews frequently praise clear explanations, detailed updates, and keeping customers informed about the work and arrival time. Speed (5) Customers note fast service, including same-day help, prompt arrivals, and efficient completion of the job. Service (5) Reviewers describe the overall experience as great service, with technicians making sure customers were happy and cared for. Reliability (5) Customers say the work was done as promised, the repairs held up well, and the results were dependable and effective. Workmanship (5) Reviews highlight quality repairs and installations, including jobs done perfectly, fixed correctly, and finished in excellent time. Friendliness (5) Technicians are often described as nice, kind, friendly, and easy to do business with. Responsiveness (4) Reviewers appreciate quick response to appointments and technicians calling ahead with arrival times, showing strong attentiveness to customer needs.

Recent Reviews from Shirley, NY

Leola Gonzalez

? At the completion of every job, all Precision customers that provide contact information are sent a request to review our business on our website. 1 2 3 4 5
Shirley, NY 03/20/2026

Person was polite and very informed. It was a pleasure dealing with him.

Service: Garage Door Repair

Steve Stein

? At the completion of every job, all Precision customers that provide contact information are sent a request to review our business on our website. 1 2 3 4 5
Shirley, NY 08/20/2025

Danny was very nice came sooner then expected and explained everything with detail and made sure I was happy at the end with the work.

Danny S

Service Technician Team: Danny S

Service: Garage Door Repair

Product: Springs

Steve Trobiano

? At the completion of every job, all Precision customers that provide contact information are sent a request to review our business on our website. 1 2 3 4 5
Shirley, NY 08/26/2024

Your tech John was a pleasure to do business with. Very informative and did the job perfect.

Service: Garage Door Repair

Product: Springs

Chris Nolan

? At the completion of every job, all Precision customers that provide contact information are sent a request to review our business on our website. 1 2 3 4 5
Shirley, NY 07/09/2024

Shane was a true professional,and a gentleman. He did a great job. Nice to see people who care about the customer. Thank you

Shane F

Location Leader: Shane F

Service: Broken Garage Door Spring Repair

Gregory & Corrine Coleman

? At the completion of every job, all Precision customers that provide contact information are sent a request to review our business on our website. 1 2 3 4 5
Shirley, NY 02/21/2024

WE MOST TRULY LOVE OUR NEW GARAGE DOOR. THE INSTALLER JEFF RIED WAS VERY PROFESSIONAL. HE CALLED US AND ARRIVED PROMPTLY ON TIME. JEFF WAS COURTEUS AND FINISHED THE JOB IN EXCELLENT TIME,HE CLEANED UP AND TOOK EVERYTHING WITH HIM,INCLUDING THE OLD GARAGE DOOR.JEFF EXPLAINED HOW TO PROPERLY OPEN AND CLOSE THE GARAGE DOOR.WE WILL DEFINITELY BE USING PRECISION GARAGE AND DOOR IN THE FUTURE, WE HIGHLY RECOMMEND THIS COMPANY FOR ALL YOUR GARAGE DOOR NEEDS.GREG AND CORRINE.

Service: Install Garage Doors

Laura Boge

? At the completion of every job, all Precision customers that provide contact information are sent a request to review our business on our website. 1 2 3 4 5
Shirley, NY 12/08/2023

Thank you Doug we were totally satisfied with the work done by your technician Danny he was helpful and knowledgeable explaining everything to us we will definitely recommend you to anyone looking for garage door work thank you again Laura B

Danny S

Service Technician Team: Danny S

Service: Broken Garage Door Spring Repair

Michael Kelly

? At the completion of every job, all Precision customers that provide contact information are sent a request to review our business on our website. 1 2 3 4 5
Shirley, NY 10/31/2020

Very impressed with this company! Same day impeccable service by Robert Weber! Would highly recommend!

Rob W

Location Leader: Rob W

Service: Broken Garage Door Spring Repair

James Ulrich

? At the completion of every job, all Precision customers that provide contact information are sent a request to review our business on our website. 1 2 3 4 5
Shirley, NY 10/09/2020

The technician was friendly, professional and knowledgeable. Thank you.

Rob W

Location Leader: Rob W

Service: Garage Door Repair

Mack Serres

? At the completion of every job, all Precision customers that provide contact information are sent a request to review our business on our website. 1 2 3 4 5
Shirley, NY 08/18/2018

I was very happy with the job that was done by Brendan Serrano. He was personable and knew what he was doing. My one disappointment was the price of the materials, which I could have bought at Home Depot or Lowe's for a fraction of what I had to pay Precision Door Service. You will probably say that your parts are of a better quality than those that the stores sell but the vast difference in price makes that difficult for me to believe. Although Brendan replaced a couple of springs and cables I didn't think that the bill for $664.79 was a fair amount to charge.

Service: Broken Garage Door Spring Repair

Bill Deinzer

? At the completion of every job, all Precision customers that provide contact information are sent a request to review our business on our website. 1 2 3 4 5
Shirley, NY 07/09/2018

EXCELLENT JOB!! Showed up on time, Technician Brendan was great! Understood the problem, explained the repair, and fixed in a timely fashion. I would recommend this company.

Service: Broken Garage Door Spring Repair

Product: Springs

Dennis Grant

? At the completion of every job, all Precision customers that provide contact information are sent a request to review our business on our website. 1 2 3 4 5
Shirley, NY 05/01/2018

Brandon was extremely professional and efficient. He kept us up to date by calling us on his arrival time. Even though the make of our door was not compatible to their parts, he reconstructed our set up and it's now working better than before and much safer. We were very happy with the work and would recommend this company again.

Service: Broken Garage Door Spring Repair

Wayne Savage

? At the completion of every job, all Precision customers that provide contact information are sent a request to review our business on our website. 1 2 3 4 5
Shirley, NY 08/12/2016

My experience with Precision was terrific. Everything that was promised was done on time and with impressive efficiency. Our installers, Greg and Jeff were just great. In a little over two hours we had a beautiful new garage door that worked perfectly with the Liftmaster Garage Door Opener. We were impressed by Mike for his detailed explanation of what was needed for this project. Thank you for a wonderful experience.

Service: Install Garage Doors

Product: Belt Drive Garage Door Opener

Anthony Trani

? At the completion of every job, all Precision customers that provide contact information are sent a request to review our business on our website. 1 2 3 4 5
Shirley, NY 05/27/2016

Brian Meinsen was courteous, respectful & informative. He was kind enough to explain the work he was doing. A fine young man.

Service: Garage Door Opener Repair

Product: Springs

Joseph Minter

? At the completion of every job, all Precision customers that provide contact information are sent a request to review our business on our website. 1 2 3 4 5
Shirley, NY 06/30/2015

Very good job. Communication was excellent. Would recommend to friends. Great service

Service: Garage Door Repair

Product: Springs

Debbie Potteiger

? At the completion of every job, all Precision customers that provide contact information are sent a request to review our business on our website. 1 2 3 4 5
Shirley, NY 03/14/2015

I am very happy with the service I received. The repair technician, Tom was precessional, kind and very informative! He did a great job and I will definitely use this company again due to his work!

Service: Garage Door Repair

Ready to Experience 5-Star Service?

Join your Shirley neighbors and let our experts take care of your garage door.

Huntington / Smithtown Area (631) 482-7236
Oyster Bay Area (516) 360-0045
North Hempstead Area (516) 360-0045
Hempstead Area (516) 360-0045
Massapequa Area (516) 360-0045
Babylon / Bay Shore Area (631) 482-7236
Brookhaven Area (631) 779-1182
Port Jefferson Area (631) 779-1182
North Fork (631) 779-1182
The Hamptons (631) 779-1182
Precision Garage Door Service of Long Island
Office: (516) 927-8686
27 Dubon Ct.
Suite B

Farmingdale, NY 11735
Precision Overhead Garage Door Service
Office: (631) 494-3195
417 Lincoln Street
Riverhead, NY 11901
Precision Garage Door Service of Long Island
Office: (631) 203-6228
197 New York Ave
Unit A

Huntington, NY 11743
Precision Garage Door Service of Long Island
Office: (516) 231-1644
1461 Franklin Ave
Suite# 10-4

Garden City, NY 11530

License

Suffolk County HIC
#54225-H