4.9 1 2 3 4 5 66 Reviews

From Setauket- East Setauket, NY Homeowners

Garage Door Repair in Setauket- East Setauket, NY

Precision Garage Door

Same-day garage door repair in Setauket- East Setauket, NY, with 24/7 live phone support, openers, new garage door installation & emergency service. We Fix Garage Doors Right ®.

Garage Door Repair in Setauket- East Setauket, NY FREE Service Call With Any Repair Valued at $69

Serving Setauket- East Setauket, NY

Proudly serving the Setauket- East Setauket, NY community with same day service.

Service truck

Local Garage Door Repair in Setauket- East Setauket, NY

Precision Garage Door of Long Island provides same-day garage door repair in Setauket- East Setauket, NY, with 24/7 live phone support. We repair garage doors and openers of nearly all makes and models and provide free estimates on new garage doors and openers.

Setauket- East Setauket, NY homeowners call us for broken springs, noisy or malfunctioning doors, garage door opener problems, and doors that won't open or close properly. Our technicians provide clear explanations and upfront pricing before work begins.

The reviews below are from customers who have used Precision Garage Door for service in and around Setauket- East Setauket and reflect their experiences with our technicians, repairs, and customer service.

Same Day Service

We fix it fast, often the same day

Upfront Pricing

Honest, flat-rate pricing with no surprises

Local & Trusted

Proudly serving local communities

Map of Setauket- East Setauket, NY

Serving Setauket- East Setauket, NY

and surrounding communities

View all Service Areas

What Customers are Saying

Summary based on the 65 most recent customer reviews

Customers in Setauket-East Setauket describe Precision Garage Door of Long Island as a highly professional and reliable garage door company that responds quickly, explains repair options clearly, and delivers efficient, high-quality work. Reviewers repeatedly praise courteous technicians, smooth installation and repair experiences, and helpful follow-through such as setup guidance, warranties, and prompt service scheduling. The strongest sentiment centers on knowledgeable service, clear communication, and dependable results that leave doors working properly and customers confident in the outcome.

What Customers in Your Area Mention Most

Professionalism (36) Reviewers consistently describe technicians as professional, polite, courteous, and well-mannered. Communication (24) Customers praise clear explanations of problems, repair options, costs, and follow-up instructions. Speed (22) Many reviews highlight quick diagnoses, efficient repairs, and fast completion of the work. Responsiveness (19) Customers frequently note prompt callbacks, same-day or next-day appointments, and timely arrival. Expertise (18) Reviewers value the technicians’ knowledge, thorough inspections, and ability to identify issues accurately. Service (17) The company is praised for courteous, helpful service and strong overall customer care from scheduling through completion. Workmanship (16) Customers report that repairs and installations are done carefully, correctly, and with strong attention to detail. Friendliness (15) Technicians are often described as friendly, personable, pleasant, and easy to work with. Trustworthiness (10) Reviewers express confidence in honest assessments, warranty support, and technicians who stand behind their work.

Recent Reviews from Setauket- East Setauket, NY

Anita Scheifele

? At the completion of every job, all Precision customers that provide contact information are sent a request to review our business on our website. 1 2 3 4 5

Honestly it was a random choice after googling garage door repair Best decision ever!! Kelvin Apple was such an awesome technician and person. I would highly recommend your service because of this man He solved multiple issues, explained everything Very positive experience

Service: Garage Door Opener Repair

Product: Belt Drive Garage Door Opener

Udayan Rane

? At the completion of every job, all Precision customers that provide contact information are sent a request to review our business on our website. 1 2 3 4 5

Labor Rate & Part Rates are very high. Precision Charges labor rate $ 299.00 + Tax which is very high in Garage Door Service Industries. All other service & parts rates are also very high. Even if you ask a simple technical question to the technician, they will tell you that we are going to charge for the service. Customer's shop round and ask the labor rate before contacting any companies.

Response from Brandon Falone, President Business Owner

Hello JD, thank you for your feedback. We’re truly sorry to hear about your experience. We would love the opportunity to speak with you and make things right. We have attempted to contact you. Please reach out to us at your earliest convenience so we can work toward a resolution.

Service: Garage Door Repair

Donna Hane

? At the completion of every job, all Precision customers that provide contact information are sent a request to review our business on our website. 1 2 3 4 5

I was contacted as to when I could expect the technician to arrive. Danny introduced himself and upon inspection of my garage opener and springs, explained my 2 options clearly, with prices and warranties. The work was completed quickly and everything was cleaned up. I was then instructed on how to use the outside control panel. Danny was very patient when I messed up the code the first time. He did not leave until he was sure I could use everything correctly.

Response from Brandon Falone, President Business Owner

Hi Donna, It’s great to hear Danny explained your options clearly and ensured you felt confident using the system before he left. Thank you for choosing Precision Garage Door Service.

Danny S

Service Technician Team: Danny S

Service: Broken Garage Door Spring Repair

Product: Garage Door Opener

Manny Kutnowsky

? At the completion of every job, all Precision customers that provide contact information are sent a request to review our business on our website. 1 2 3 4 5

The technician Danny Salas was excellent, truly a professional, polite, courteous and a real gentleman. I would recommend Precision to anyone.

Response from Doug Business Owner

Hi Manny, Danny is an excellent technician, and we're glad his professionalism stood out during your service. Thank you for the recommendation. Thank you for choosing Precision Garage Door Service.

Comment from Manny Kutnowsky

He is the best you are lucky to have him

Danny S

Service Technician Team: Danny S

Service: Garage Door Opener Install

Product: Garage Door Opener

Joseph Bianco e

? At the completion of every job, all Precision customers that provide contact information are sent a request to review our business on our website. 1 2 3 4 5

I am very pleased with Precision Garage. From the very beginning, the sales rep (Michael) was excellent, to the financing options, scheduling, to install, they all have been great. Brian and Joe installed my doors today, they were both professional , personable and knowledgable. The walked me through how to take care of the doors, code programing and setting up the app through the phone. They worked neat and did a very good job. The doors have a nice seal, quiet motors and look great. Thank you to them and all of the staff at Precision. Give them a call before you commit to someone else, you will not be disappointed.

Response from Doug Business Owner

Hi Joseph, We’re thrilled to hear your experience from sales through installation was so positive. Michael, Brian and Joe will be grateful for your kind words. Thank you for choosing Precision Garage Door Service.

Joe M

Door Installation Team: Joe M

Service: Install Garage Doors

Product: Garage Doors

David Chu

? At the completion of every job, all Precision customers that provide contact information are sent a request to review our business on our website. 1 2 3 4 5

Came two days after call on as a Saturday, diagnosed in one minute, replaced motor in one hour. Professional and wonderful specialist!!

Response from Doug Business Owner

Hi David, Great to know your technician diagnosed the issue quickly and completed everything professionally. Thank you for choosing Precision Garage Door Service.

Ryan S

Service Technician Team: Ryan S

Service: Garage Door Opener Repair

Product: Garage Door Opener

Patricia Williamson

? At the completion of every job, all Precision customers that provide contact information are sent a request to review our business on our website. 1 2 3 4 5

I highly recommend Precision Garage Door Service. I have been using them for several years now. They are easy to contact, they respond very promptly, and are very security mindful. They send a photo of the technician who is responding and notify you when he is on the way. I contacted them Wednesday afternoon regarding my keypad which I saw was not working because there was rust in the area where the batteries are installed. They responded this morning and replaced the keypad under warranty. I am very appreciative of their service. area where the batteries are installed. They responded this morning and replaced the keypad under warranty. I am

Ryan S

Service Technician Team: Ryan S

Service: Garage Door Opener Repair

Product: Remotes / Keypad

Edward Lenahan

? At the completion of every job, all Precision customers that provide contact information are sent a request to review our business on our website. 1 2 3 4 5

Very happy with the service , from Mia who helped me schedule the appointment to Ryan who came to do the tune up. Ryan was early, professional and explained everything he was doing. They were the company that installed my door and I will always use them for service . Ed Lenahan

Response from Doug Business Owner

Hi Edward, We’re so glad to hear Mia made scheduling easy and that Ryan provided professional, thorough service during your tune-up. It’s great to know you trust us for both installation and ongoing care. Thank you for choosing Precision Garage Door Service.

Ryan S

Service Technician Team: Ryan S

Service: Garage Door Opener Install

Lois Ann Link

? At the completion of every job, all Precision customers that provide contact information are sent a request to review our business on our website. 1 2 3 4 5

My 22 year old garage door wasn’t opening properly for a week. I had used Precision in the past and remembered Danny Salas who did a great job then and now. Danny is very professional and a great guy. He was at my house in an hour He took time to explain what the problem was and in another hour I had an updated opener, key pad inside and outside and two openers for the car. Again, he took time to explain how everything worked. I’m very happy with the job he did, everything is working perfectly. Danny is The Best !

Response from Doug Business Owner

Hi Lois, We’re so glad Danny was able to provide prompt, professional service and take the time to explain everything clearly. It’s wonderful to hear your new opener and accessories are working perfectly and that you’re happy with the results. Your loyalty and kind words mean a lot to us! Thank you for choosing Precision Garage Door Service.

Danny S

Service Technician Team: Danny S

Service: Garage Door Opener Install

Product: Remotes / Keypad

D.Day

? At the completion of every job, all Precision customers that provide contact information are sent a request to review our business on our website. 1 2 3 4 5

8-6-25 Danny and Kelvin did a great job. They identified the problem, fixed it quickly, and they were pleasant and professional. I would recommend Precision Door Service to any one needing to service their garage door opener.

Danny S

Service Technician Team: Danny S

Service: Garage Door Opener Repair

Leslie Quinn

? At the completion of every job, all Precision customers that provide contact information are sent a request to review our business on our website. 1 2 3 4 5

Precision Garage Door Service came to my rescue today!! Not only did they set up a same day appointment for me to fix my broken garage door, the team they sent out- Ryan and Kevin were wonderful. They were very professional, carefully evaluating the door and all the equipment . They explained their assessment to me in terms I could understand and then proceeded to fix the problem in a very efficient manner. I am extremely satisfied with their work and I would highly recommend this company.

Ryan S

Service Technician Team: Ryan S

Service: Garage Door Opener Repair

Product: Springs

Richard Berger

? At the completion of every job, all Precision customers that provide contact information are sent a request to review our business on our website. 1 2 3 4 5

Great company. Jacob was a total professional. He did a wonderful job fixing the problem quickly and perfectly. Every time I use your company the result has always been perfection. Keep up the great work. Your company is the best there is at what they do. Thank you very much. M

Service: Garage Door Repair

John Digiacomo

? At the completion of every job, all Precision customers that provide contact information are sent a request to review our business on our website. 1 2 3 4 5

Our Service Technician was pleasure to deal with. He was professional, personable and accommodating. The service was performed on the same day I called to schedule an appointment. Their Van was fully stocked with all the parts and accessories necessary to complete the job. I would highly recommend them to others.

Danny S

Service Technician Team: Danny S

Service: Garage Door Repair

Product: Garage Door Opener

Glenn Davis

? At the completion of every job, all Precision customers that provide contact information are sent a request to review our business on our website. 1 2 3 4 5

Great service provided by Precision Door . The technician Jacob was very professional and made the visit feel very comfortable. The way Jacob performed his job was excellent as he exhibited what class service is all about.

Service: Broken Garage Door Spring Repair

Bruce Schery

? At the completion of every job, all Precision customers that provide contact information are sent a request to review our business on our website. 1 2 3 4 5

Danny, your technician was excellent however the price for what he felt needed to be done was exorbitant. Your 3” pulleys were way overpriced and I was able to pick up 4 heavy duty for less than $20. I can swap those out myself and save hundreds.

Danny S

Service Technician Team: Danny S

Service: Broken Garage Door Spring Repair

Product: Springs

Richard Miller

? At the completion of every job, all Precision customers that provide contact information are sent a request to review our business on our website. 1 2 3 4 5

Excellent and timely service by Danny S. Full and detailed explanation of problems and repairs needed. Easily understood. Cost discussed at length. Work completed in a very efficient and successful manner by a very personable, enthusiastic Danny.

Danny S

Service Technician Team: Danny S

Service: Garage Door Repair

Frank Wieland

? At the completion of every job, all Precision customers that provide contact information are sent a request to review our business on our website. 1 2 3 4 5

This is the third time Precision Garage Door has assisted me with maintenance issues. The service has always been prompt, professional. Their personnel are polite, professional and most importantly, competent. Thanks again for your help. Frank Wieland, Setauket, NY

Danny S

Service Technician Team: Danny S

Service: Broken Garage Door Spring Repair

Bob M (Setauket)

? At the completion of every job, all Precision customers that provide contact information are sent a request to review our business on our website. 1 2 3 4 5

The technician Robert who was assigned to fix my garage door did an amazing job. Professional, knowledgable and thorough. Robert made sure that the door worked as it should and that I was satisfied. Very happy with the experience.

Rob W

Location Leader: Rob W

Service: Garage Door Repair

Rebecca P

? At the completion of every job, all Precision customers that provide contact information are sent a request to review our business on our website. 1 2 3 4 5

The best! Robert was professional, timely and did great work. He explained what needed to be fixed and finished the job in 20 minutes. No up sell no hassle. Awesome job. Thanks Robert!

Rob W

Location Leader: Rob W

Service: Garage Door Repair

Alan Goldberg

? At the completion of every job, all Precision customers that provide contact information are sent a request to review our business on our website. 1 2 3 4 5

Andrew did a great job. Very personable and worked quickly to fix the problem.

Service: Garage Door Repair

John LaPerla

? At the completion of every job, all Precision customers that provide contact information are sent a request to review our business on our website. 1 2 3 4 5

I had my garage door opener replaced by your technician Danny Salas. He diagnosed the problem w/ my existing unit and explained the issue. He provided me w/ my options and installed the new unit. He helped me w/ downloading the app that works w/ the unit and also assisted me in programming the opener in my car. Totally professional and knowledgeable. I would not hesitate to recommend Precision and especially Danny

Danny S

Service Technician Team: Danny S

Service: Garage Door Opener Install

Product: Garage Door Opener

Kenneth Walch

? At the completion of every job, all Precision customers that provide contact information are sent a request to review our business on our website. 1 2 3 4 5

The repair person was professional and informative. He was able to identify and fix my problem rapidly.

Service: Garage Door Opener Repair

Michael Kalakowski

? At the completion of every job, all Precision customers that provide contact information are sent a request to review our business on our website. 1 2 3 4 5

first class service and repair. Used service previously very good price. technician was highly knowledgeable of motor replacement and very professional. service is highly recommended

Danny S

Service Technician Team: Danny S

Service: Garage Door Opener Install

Product: Garage Door Opener

Roy West

? At the completion of every job, all Precision customers that provide contact information are sent a request to review our business on our website. 1 2 3 4 5

The workers were very professional and courteous and did a good job.

Danny S

Service Technician Team: Danny S

Service: Garage Door Opener Install

Product: Garage Door Opener

Robert Robinson

? At the completion of every job, all Precision customers that provide contact information are sent a request to review our business on our website. 1 2 3 4 5

serviice prompt,courteous and professional Precision installed our garage door previously

Service: Garage Door Repair

Carolyn S

? At the completion of every job, all Precision customers that provide contact information are sent a request to review our business on our website. 1 2 3 4 5

This week I had my old garage doors updated with new ones from Precision Doors. The technician who came, Brian Meinsen, installed two doors all by himself. They are so much easier to open than my old ones! Thanks for the quick, good work. The house has much better curbside appeal now.

Service: Install Garage Doors

Product: Garage Doors

Bob M (Setauket)

? At the completion of every job, all Precision customers that provide contact information are sent a request to review our business on our website. 1 2 3 4 5

I chose Precision Door on a recommendation from a friend. I was not disappointed. Danny, who sold me my doors was also the technician who came to fix a broken spring. Danny is very professional, knowledgeable, and quick. Your company is only as good as the support that it provides to the product it sells. Precision stands behind its product as evident in the quality of support with technicians like Danny. Will recommend Precision to my friends and family.

Danny S

Service Technician Team: Danny S

Service: Broken Garage Door Spring Repair

Fran Davanzo

? At the completion of every job, all Precision customers that provide contact information are sent a request to review our business on our website. 1 2 3 4 5

I was very pleased with the overall service I received from Precision Door. From the first phone call to the appointment scheduled to the prompt arrival of the service technician Andrew and finally the repair itself. Everyone I dealt with was polite, prompt and professional. A pleasure to do business with!

Service: Garage Door Opener Repair

Product: Garage Door Opener

Dolores

? At the completion of every job, all Precision customers that provide contact information are sent a request to review our business on our website. 1 2 3 4 5

We will NEVER use another garage door company. Precision was at my house w/in an hour of my call - and repaired the problem on the spot!! These days it's a miracle to have resolution in a month let alone w/in hours. You guys are the best!!!

Rob W

Location Leader: Rob W

Service: Garage Door Opener Repair

Product: Garage Door Opener

Tony Cottone

? At the completion of every job, all Precision customers that provide contact information are sent a request to review our business on our website. 1 2 3 4 5

I had a garage door problem, made a phone call, Jessie came on a Sunday. Problem resolved! He was knowledgeable and very pleasant. I'm glad I called Precision and will do so again should need arise. Tony

Service: Garage Door Repair

Ready to Experience 5-Star Service?

Join your Setauket- East Setauket neighbors and let our experts take care of your garage door.

Huntington / Smithtown Area (631) 482-7236
Oyster Bay Area (516) 360-0045
North Hempstead Area (516) 360-0045
Hempstead Area (516) 360-0045
Massapequa Area (516) 360-0045
Babylon / Bay Shore Area (631) 482-7236
Brookhaven Area (631) 779-1182
Port Jefferson Area (631) 779-1182
North Fork (631) 779-1182
The Hamptons (631) 779-1182
Precision Garage Door Service of Long Island
Office: (516) 927-8686
27 Dubon Ct.
Suite B

Farmingdale, NY 11735
Precision Overhead Garage Door Service
Office: (631) 494-3195
417 Lincoln Street
Riverhead, NY 11901
Precision Garage Door Service of Long Island
Office: (631) 203-6228
197 New York Ave
Unit A

Huntington, NY 11743
Precision Garage Door Service of Long Island
Office: (516) 231-1644
1461 Franklin Ave
Suite# 10-4

Garden City, NY 11530

License

Suffolk County HIC
#54225-H