5.0 1 2 3 4 5 524 Reviews

From Oyster Bay, NY Homeowners

Garage Door Repair in Oyster Bay, NY - Page 2

Precision Garage Door

Same-day garage door repair in Oyster Bay, with 24/7 live phone support, openers, new garage door installation & emergency service. We Fix Garage Doors Right ®.

Garage Door Repair in Oyster Bay, NY FREE Service Call With Any Repair Valued at $69

Serving Oyster Bay, NY

Proudly serving the Oyster Bay community with same day service.

Service truck

Local Garage Door Repair in Oyster Bay, NY

Precision Garage Door of Long Island provides same-day garage door repair in Oyster Bay, with 24/7 live phone support. We repair garage doors and openers of nearly all makes and models and provide free estimates on new garage doors and openers.

Oyster Bay homeowners call us for broken springs, noisy or malfunctioning doors, garage door opener problems, and doors that won't open or close properly. Our technicians provide clear explanations and upfront pricing before work begins.

The reviews below are from customers who have used Precision Garage Door for service in and around Oyster Bay and reflect their experiences with our technicians, repairs, and customer service.

Same Day Service

We fix it fast, often the same day

Upfront Pricing

Honest, flat-rate pricing with no surprises

Local & Trusted

Proudly serving local communities

What Customers are Saying

Summary based on the 524 most recent customer reviews

Customers across Oyster Bay and nearby Long Island communities consistently describe Precision Garage Door of Long Island as prompt, professional, and easy to work with. Reviews most often praise the technicians’ knowledge, clear explanations, and no-pressure guidance, along with fast problem-solving, clean workmanship, and reliable communication from booking through completion. Many customers also mention same-day or quick response and note that the completed repairs or installations leave doors and openers working smoothly and, in some cases, more quietly than before.

What Customers in Your Area Mention Most

Professionalism (254) Customers repeatedly describe the team as professional, courteous, and respectful, often noting polished conduct and a pleasant experience from start to finish. Expertise (214) Reviews frequently praise the technicians’ knowledge, ability to diagnose issues quickly, and clear explanations of what needed to be done and why. Communication (198) Customers value the clear communication throughout the process, including updates, calls ahead of arrival, explanations of options, and follow-up that keeps them informed. Responsiveness (176) Many reviews highlight quick response times, same-day or next-day appointments, and prompt arrival when customers needed help. Speed (168) Customers consistently note fast service and efficient completion of repairs and installations, with many jobs finished quickly once the technician arrived. Service (161) Reviewers praise the overall customer service as helpful, accommodating, and pleasant, with many saying the company is easy to work with and delivers a positive end-to-end experience. Workmanship (149) Customers regularly say the repairs and installations are done well, neatly, and thoroughly, with doors and openers working properly or like new afterward. Friendliness (142) The technicians are often described as friendly, polite, personable, and easy to talk to, which many customers say made the visit more comfortable. Trustworthiness (111) Reviews commonly mention honesty, transparency, and low-pressure recommendations, with technicians presenting options clearly and helping customers feel confident in the decision.

Recent Reviews from Oyster Bay, NY

Steve M

? At the completion of every job, all Precision customers that provide contact information are sent a request to review our business on our website. 1 2 3 4 5
Plainview, NY 06/10/2026

Precision kept me in loop with reminders , email updates the day of service and a phone call from technician when he was on his way.Jason the technician was friendly , courteous and efficient taking care of the issue I reached out to precision for.

Service: Garage Door Opener Install

Product: Opener

Amy Sussman

? At the completion of every job, all Precision customers that provide contact information are sent a request to review our business on our website. 1 2 3 4 5
Woodbury, NY 06/09/2026

I had the best experience. Jason was polite nice and you are very lucky to have him . Amy Sussman

Service: Broken Garage Door Spring Repair

Colbey Strum

? At the completion of every job, all Precision customers that provide contact information are sent a request to review our business on our website. 1 2 3 4 5
Plainview, NY 06/08/2026

Precision did a phenomenal job installing my new motor and changing out old parts. They were on time and called before they arrived. John Fusco was professional and they were very fair on their prices. 100% recommend

Service: Garage Door Opener Install

Product: Belt Drive Garage Door Opener

Vera Zacek

? At the completion of every job, all Precision customers that provide contact information are sent a request to review our business on our website. 1 2 3 4 5

Your technician John Fusco was knowledgeable and a very friendly people person. He helped me with h the problem I was having with my remote. He is an asset to your company!

Service: Garage Door Opener Repair

Marianne Kenary

? At the completion of every job, all Precision customers that provide contact information are sent a request to review our business on our website. 1 2 3 4 5
Oyster Bay, NY 05/19/2026

Great service, prompt & efficient ! Excellent communication from booking an appointment thru to completion of service . Mike was very patient & knowledgeable while troubleshooting our garage door problem. He completed the job & solved our issue.I will definitely recommend this company & use again when needed ! Many thanks for a job well done !

Service: Garage Door Repair

Jay Sherman

? At the completion of every job, all Precision customers that provide contact information are sent a request to review our business on our website. 1 2 3 4 5
Plainview, NY 05/18/2026

Review re: Jay Sherman 10 Sagamore Drive Plainview, NY 11803 John Fusco just completed a service call at my home. He set me up with a new remote for my garage door, programmed my vehicle, greased the hinges and thoroughly checked everything. John was excellent---thorough, patient, and made sure I understood everything necessary. He explained how to use the car remote built-in feature, how to open & close manually in case of a blackout, explained certain features on the keypad in the garage, how to grease the hinges and more. I definitely feel comfortable now and everything is working perfectly. I will spread reviews on Google, Facebook and on the Hamlet Facebook site. I'd like to have John perform future service calls if possible. He's a genuinely nice guy.

Service: Garage Door Repair

Product: Remotes / Keypad

Janice Dohrman

? At the completion of every job, all Precision customers that provide contact information are sent a request to review our business on our website. 1 2 3 4 5

This is "Part One" of what will be a two-part review. A few weeks ago, our garage door broke; it seems that a spring gave out. Since this was a 25 year old door, a Craftsman one purchased from Sears (RIP, Sears...you were great!), I knew that we needed to find another repair service. After doing my research, and seeing the great reviews for Precision, I gave them a call. Within 24 hours, I had one of their techs at the house. What I loved and what impressed me from the beginning, was the close contact they provided. Not only did we get an email confirmation, but we also received text messages tracking the tech, and giving us a photo with some background information about them. This was reassuring, as it is nice to know who is showing up, and that the person is who they say they are. We met Nick, who was from the first moment we met him, friendly, professional, and knowledgeable. He took his time, evaluated the situation, and provided us with 3 options to consider. Not for one minute did we feel pressured or upsold; we felt confident and informed. In the end, we opted for a new door. We are in no rush, so we will be waiting 4-6 weeks for the door. What impressed us further, was, when Nick was about to leave, he told us that he may have something in the truck that would help the door function better while we waited for the new door to be installed later this summer. WHO DOES THIS!!!! Nick was great, and a true representation of what exceptional customer service should look like. We look forward to getting our new door installed some time in early July. Stay tuned for "Part Two".

Nick U

Service Technician Team: Nick U

Service: Garage Door Repair

Product: Garage Doors

Ann Jacobs

? At the completion of every job, all Precision customers that provide contact information are sent a request to review our business on our website. 1 2 3 4 5

We used Precision in the past and were pleased with the prompt service. Yesterday Our garage door was making a funny noise so we called Precision. Lewis and the other technician were professional and correctly identified the issue and explained our options. We are extremely pleased with the service we received and would most definitely recommend Precision in the future. Thank you so much!!

Lewis R

Service Technician Team: Lewis R

Service: Garage Door Opener Install

Product: Garage Door Opener

Steve Amateau

? At the completion of every job, all Precision customers that provide contact information are sent a request to review our business on our website. 1 2 3 4 5
Plainview, NY 04/28/2026

Great service. My technician Nick was great. Smart n really nice guy. Not an easy repair but he solved it pretty quickly. Would definitely recommend

Nick U

Service Technician Team: Nick U

Service: Garage Door Opener Repair

Linda Roesch

? At the completion of every job, all Precision customers that provide contact information are sent a request to review our business on our website. 1 2 3 4 5

Excellent polite service. On time and helpful.

Lewis R

Service Technician Team: Lewis R

Service: Garage Door Opener Repair

Product: Garage Door Opener

Adam Bellow

? At the completion of every job, all Precision customers that provide contact information are sent a request to review our business on our website. 1 2 3 4 5
Plainview, NY 04/10/2026

Great service. Quick and professional.

Israel H

Service Technician Team: Israel H

Service: Garage Door Opener Install

Product: Opener

David Black

? At the completion of every job, all Precision customers that provide contact information are sent a request to review our business on our website. 1 2 3 4 5
Oyster Bay, NY 04/06/2026

Precision handled my request for an estimate with courtesy and professionalism. Their tech, John Fusco, arrived on time and I was given ample notice. Our garage lift master died and I was hoping for repair instead of replacement. John understood my concerns, took the time to consult with his office to provide me with options. I chose full replacement with lifetime guarantee in the end because I trusted these guys. Installation was smooth and the professional demeanor and willingness to go the extra mile never ended. Color me grateful.

Service: Garage Door Opener Install

Product: Garage Door Opener

Nancy Krieg

? At the completion of every job, all Precision customers that provide contact information are sent a request to review our business on our website. 1 2 3 4 5
Plainview, NY 04/04/2026

We had an issue with our garage door today and called Precision to schedule a service call. Despite it being a weekend, they arranged for a technician to come to our house and he was quickly able to resolve our problem. We would definitely recommend this company.

Israel H

Service Technician Team: Israel H

Service: Garage Door Repair

Ronni Pearce

? At the completion of every job, all Precision customers that provide contact information are sent a request to review our business on our website. 1 2 3 4 5
Plainview, NY 03/31/2026

Shane was great. Very pleasant, friendly and knowledgeable. Would welcome him again to fix my repair needs.

Shane F

Location Leader: Shane F

Service: Garage Door Opener Install

Product: Remotes / Keypad

Robert Spielman

? At the completion of every job, all Precision customers that provide contact information are sent a request to review our business on our website. 1 2 3 4 5
Woodbury, NY 03/25/2026

The service person John Russo was just excellent in every way. Arrived timely. Explained everything. Worked quickly and edgy. Cleaned everything up. You should be proud he represents your company

Service: Garage Door Opener Install

Product: Opener

Brian Hayes

? At the completion of every job, all Precision customers that provide contact information are sent a request to review our business on our website. 1 2 3 4 5
Syosset, NY 03/24/2026

Nick to an outstanding job!!Thank you!!

Nick U

Service Technician Team: Nick U

Service: Install Garage Doors

Product: Garage Door Opener

Keith Tamayo

? At the completion of every job, all Precision customers that provide contact information are sent a request to review our business on our website. 1 2 3 4 5
Syosset, NY 02/21/2026

Precision Garage Door was outstanding. They responded incredibly fast to my emergency service request on a Saturday, which was a huge relief. The technician arrived promptly, was professional, knowledgeable, and had everything fixed quickly. The whole process was smooth, efficient, and stress-free. Excellent service and reliability—I highly recommend Precision Garage Door to anyone who needs fast, dependable help.

Response from Brandon Falone, President Business Owner

Hi Keith, Glad we could respond quickly to your emergency call and get everything resolved. Thank you for choosing Precision Garage Door Service

Lewis R

Service Technician Team: Lewis R

Service: Garage Door Repair

Charlie M

? At the completion of every job, all Precision customers that provide contact information are sent a request to review our business on our website. 1 2 3 4 5
Syosset, NY 02/14/2026

I first used Precision in 2017 and they were great. Today, I had another tech (Nick) visit the house. He was extremely professional. He called prior to coming and let me know his eta. He presented my options without pressuring me into anything. He worked quickly and left without leaving any rubbish behind. I am very satisfied with Precision and the techs they employ. Very refreshing to see there are still squared away companies out there.

Nick U

Service Technician Team: Nick U

Service: Garage Door Repair

Product: Garage Door Opener

Lou Mastellone

? At the completion of every job, all Precision customers that provide contact information are sent a request to review our business on our website. 1 2 3 4 5
Glen Head, NY 02/12/2026

Lewis did a fantastic job Solid knowledge of what was needed and finished in a timely manner

Response from Brandon Falone, President Business Owner

Hi Lou, Great to hear Lewis delivered exactly what was needed and handled everything efficiently. Thank you for choosing Precision Garage Door Service.

Lewis R

Service Technician Team: Lewis R

Service: Garage Door Opener Install

Product: Belt Drive Garage Door Opener

Paul Rosenblit

? At the completion of every job, all Precision customers that provide contact information are sent a request to review our business on our website. 1 2 3 4 5
Jericho, NY 02/10/2026

Precision Garage Door of Plainview is the best. Prompt efficient service. Really amazing customer service and notifications every step of the way. From appointment, to tech arrival notifications, to follow up after the repair. Thanks for all you do!

Response from Brandon Falone, President Business Owner

Hi Paul, Thanks for recognizing the communication and attentive care from our Plainview team. Thank you for choosing Precision Garage Door Service.

Shane F

Location Leader: Shane F

Service: Garage Door Opener Repair

Mark Zim

? At the completion of every job, all Precision customers that provide contact information are sent a request to review our business on our website. 1 2 3 4 5
Woodbury, NY 02/05/2026

Precision is fantastic. Lewis came and did such a wonderful job. I would give this company infinite number of stars if I could.

Response from Doug Business Owner

Hi Mark, We’re thrilled to hear Lewis made such a great impression and that you’d rate us so highly. Thank you for choosing Precision Garage Door Service.

Lewis R

Service Technician Team: Lewis R

Service: Garage Door Repair

Arlene Orliss

? At the completion of every job, all Precision customers that provide contact information are sent a request to review our business on our website. 1 2 3 4 5
Plainview, NY 01/31/2026

Efficient, neat, polite, knew exactly what the problem was.

Response from Doug Business Owner

Hi Arlene, Glad the issue was diagnosed quickly and handled neatly and professionally. Thank you for choosing Precision Garage Door Service.

Nick U

Service Technician Team: Nick U

Service: Garage Door Repair

Karen Meyerowitz

? At the completion of every job, all Precision customers that provide contact information are sent a request to review our business on our website. 1 2 3 4 5

Luis was knowledgeable very nice and did a great job

Response from Doug Business Owner

Hi Karen, Thank you for sharing, Luis will appreciate the recognition for his work and professionalism. Thank you for choosing Precision Garage Door Service.

Lewis R

Service Technician Team: Lewis R

Service: Garage Door Repair

Product: Cables

Joseph Natter

? At the completion of every job, all Precision customers that provide contact information are sent a request to review our business on our website. 1 2 3 4 5
Plainview, NY 01/21/2026

Our garage door system was over 20 years old. It was in definite need of an overhaul. Our technician, Nick, came within hours of our calling, and did a complete overhaul of our garage door system, replacing springs, rollers, pulleys, etc., and added safety lines. Everything now is working like new.

Nick U

Service Technician Team: Nick U

Service: Garage Door Repair

Product: Springs

Lyle Borman

? At the completion of every job, all Precision customers that provide contact information are sent a request to review our business on our website. 1 2 3 4 5
Plainview, NY 01/16/2026

Sudden garage door breakdown. Precision responded immediately and Nicholas provided service. His work and description of potential options were exceptional. There was never the “hard sell” or push to upgrade beyond the basic repair. Work was completed on a timely basis and my door never sounded and ran better. Would definitely recommend them.

Nick U

Service Technician Team: Nick U

Service: Garage Door Repair

Ken W

? At the completion of every job, all Precision customers that provide contact information are sent a request to review our business on our website. 1 2 3 4 5
Jericho, NY 01/08/2026

George was courteous, professional, and efficient. He explained the options clearly and quickly performed the necessary repairs.

Response from Doug Business Owner

Hi Ken, Great to hear George provided courteous, professional, and efficient service while clearly explaining your options. Thank you for choosing Precision Garage Door Service.

Service: Broken Garage Door Spring Repair

Product: Springs

Jill Volmacka

? At the completion of every job, all Precision customers that provide contact information are sent a request to review our business on our website. 1 2 3 4 5
Glen Cove, NY 01/06/2026

I was pleased with your workers in the past and the professional work they did. Louis R was wonderful. He was on time called to tell us ahead of time so we could move our cars out of the way he was organized professional answered all our questions gave a good demonstration to how the remote worked showed us how and where the child proof sensors were and how they attached to the rail he smiled and enjoys his job. The company did a great job in hiring and training him. Thank you for having this person service our garage door. He was just wonderful. Happy New Year to you all. Jill vomacka

Response from Doug Business Owner

Hi Jill, We’re delighted Louis left such a wonderful impression. Your thoughtful feedback means a lot, and we're glad he provided such a professional and friendly experience. Thank you for choosing Precision Garage Door Service.

Lewis R

Service Technician Team: Lewis R

Service: Garage Door Opener Install

Product: Garage Door Opener

Danny Gray

? At the completion of every job, all Precision customers that provide contact information are sent a request to review our business on our website. 1 2 3 4 5
Bayville, NY 01/04/2026

Great Job

Response from Doug Business Owner

Hi Danny, Thank you for choosing Precision Garage Door Service.

Shane F

Location Leader: Shane F

Service: Garage Door Opener Install

Product: Belt Drive Garage Door Opener

Linda Horgan

? At the completion of every job, all Precision customers that provide contact information are sent a request to review our business on our website. 1 2 3 4 5
Bayville, NY 12/26/2025

Nicholas did a terrific job. Professional and a pleasure to work with.

Response from Doug Business Owner

Hi Linda, We appreciate your feedback on Nicholas. Glad his professionalism made the experience a positive one. Thank you for choosing Precision Garage Door Service.

Nick U

Service Technician Team: Nick U

Service: Garage Door Opener Install

Product: Garage Door Opener

Lynne Stebbins

? At the completion of every job, all Precision customers that provide contact information are sent a request to review our business on our website. 1 2 3 4 5
Glen Cove, NY 12/22/2025

Shane was early (!), understood the issue and repaired it with competence and efficiency. We can count on the quality of service provided, and we are happy to recommend Precision.

Response from Doug Business Owner

Hi Lynne, Great to know Shane resolved the issue quickly and effectively. We appreciate your confidence in our service. Thank you for choosing Precision Garage Door Service.

Shane F

Location Leader: Shane F

Service: Garage Door Repair

Ready to Experience 5-Star Service?

Join your Oyster Bay neighbors and let our experts take care of your garage door.

Huntington / Smithtown Area (631) 482-7236
Oyster Bay Area (516) 360-0045
North Hempstead Area (516) 360-0045
Hempstead Area (516) 360-0045
Massapequa Area (516) 360-0045
Babylon / Bay Shore Area (631) 482-7236
Brookhaven Area (631) 779-1182
Port Jefferson Area (631) 779-1182
North Fork (631) 779-1182
The Hamptons (631) 779-1182
Precision Garage Door Service of Long Island
Office: (516) 927-8686
27 Dubon Ct.
Suite B

Farmingdale, NY 11735
Precision Overhead Garage Door Service
Office: (631) 494-3195
417 Lincoln Street
Riverhead, NY 11901
Precision Garage Door Service of Long Island
Office: (631) 203-6228
197 New York Ave
Unit A

Huntington, NY 11743
Precision Garage Door Service of Long Island
Office: (516) 231-1644
1461 Franklin Ave
Suite# 10-4

Garden City, NY 11530

License

Suffolk County HIC
#54225-H